Best Gravy Separators
7 Picks Before Thanksgiving
Our #1 pick is the OXO Good Grips Good Gravy. Seven gravy separators to order before Thanksgiving on November 26, from a $10 budget pick to a glass pitcher. We checked every Amazon listing for capacity, release type, material and heat limit, and say who should skip each one.
How we picked: we shortlist by Amazon Best Seller rank and number of ratings, then compare published specs. We don’t test these products hands-on.
By Jamilur Rahman, Founder & Editor · Updated November 17, 2026
- Owner reviews checked
- Features side by side
- Quick & easy compare
- Smarter purchase

The short answer
For most kitchens, the OXO Good Grips Good Gravy 4-cup is the gravy separator to buy. America’s Test Kitchen and Reviewed both ranked it first: you squeeze the handle and the juices drain from the bottom while the fat stays on top, and a top spout is there for the last of the fat. At about $25 to $35 it suits anyone making gravy for a full Thanksgiving table.
Pick the rest by job. A bottom-release separator has a plug in its base that you open with the handle, so the juices drain out from under the fat. A pour-spout separator has a spout that starts low in the cup, so the juices pour out from under the fat. Take the OXO 4-cup pour-spout (about $15 to $25) for the simple, proven design, the Cuisipro (about $30 to $40) for the least fat in the gravy, and the Vondior (about $20 to $25) for bottom release at a lower price. Take the HIC glass pitcher (about $30 to $40) if you want no plastic, and the Bellemain (about $20 to $25) if the stock goes in hot. The Fox Run (under $10) is the budget pick for a small dinner. Skip the Fox Run for any big bird, skip the HIC if you want a stopper or a dishwasher, and skip the Cuisipro if you want markings that are easy to read.
How we picked: we started with the separators that America’s Test Kitchen, Reviewed, Serious Eats and Bustle name in their roundups, then read each live Amazon listing on November 17, 2026 for capacity, release type, material, strainer, dishwasher and heat notes, and price. We kept 4-cup models plus one small budget pick, because ATK’s testers say a true 4-cup size handles big and small batches alike. We found no well-reviewed 6 to 8 cup separator, so none is listed. We don’t claim any testing of our own: these picks come from published tests, listing specs and what owners report. Prices are bands checked November 17, 2026.
Compare them side by side
Everything that matters, in one table. Swipe to see all 7.
| Product | ![]() Best Overall OXO Good Grips Good Gravy 4 cup, bottom release | ![]() Best Pour-Spout OXO Good Grips Fat Separator 4 cup, pour spout | ![]() Best Fat Removal Cuisipro Fat Separator 4 cup, bottom release | ![]() Best Value Bottom-Release Vondior Fat Separator 4 cup, bottom release | ![]() Best Glass HIC Kitchen Glass Fat Separator 4 cup, borosilicate glass | ![]() Best for Hot Stock Bellemain 4-Cup Fat Separator 4 cup, high-top pour spout | ![]() Best Budget Fox Run Gravy Separator 1.5 cup, acrylic |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| BeastScore | 93 / 100 | 90 / 100 | 88 / 100 | 87 / 100 | 85 / 100 | 83 / 100 | 82 / 100 |
| Best for | Most families making gravy for a full table | A simple, proven design for a big batch | Cooks who want the least fat in the gravy | Bottom release on a budget | Plastic-free kitchens and gravy you reheat in the pitcher | Pouring in stock that is still hot | Small dinners and the lowest price |
| Typical price (checked November 17, 2026) | $25–$35 | $15–$25 | $30–$40 | $20–$25 | $30–$40 | $20–$25 | $10–$15 |
| Capacity | 4 cup | 4 cup (2 cup also sold) | 4 cup | 4 cup | 4 cup (32 oz) | 4 cup (1 L) | 1.5 cup |
| Release type | Bottom release + top spout | Pour spout + stopper | Bottom release | Bottom release (handle button) | Low-set spout | Pour spout + stopper | Pour spout |
| Material | Plastic | Plastic | Tritan plastic | Plastic, BPA-free | Borosilicate glass + stainless steel | Plastic, ABS-free | Acrylic |
| Strainer | Yes, removable | Yes, fine | Yes, oversized basket | Yes, built in | Yes, pierced + fine mesh | Yes | Not stated |
| Dishwasher safe | Yes, per listing | Yes, per listing | Yes, per listing | Top shelf, per listing | Hand wash, per listing | Yes, per listing | Top rack, per listing |
| Heat limit (listing) | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | 300°F (stovetop, microwave) | 400°F | Let hot liquid cool first |
| Key features |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
BeastScore here is our overall rating out of 100, based on published specs and Amazon owner reviews. Prices change daily, so tap "View on Amazon" for today's price. We may earn a small commission, at no extra cost to you. Learn more
Why each one made the list
What each pick does best, where it falls short, and the typical Amazon price when we checked.
- 1. Best Overall
OXO Good Grips Good Gravy
BeastScore 93 / 100Typically $25–$35 on Amazon (checked November 17, 2026)This is the separator the test kitchens agree on. America’s Test Kitchen named it the winner and Reviewed picked it as best overall. You pour drippings through the removable strainer, let the fat settle, then squeeze the non-slip handle and the juices drain through a silicone shut-off valve. A top spout removes leftover fat. Take it over the others for the best mix of fat removal, pour control and easy cleanup. Skip it if you want the lowest price or a glass pitcher: ATK says the valve takes a firm squeeze, it costs more than the pour-spout OXO and the Vondior, and the listing gives no heat limit.
Pros- Top pick of America’s Test Kitchen and Reviewed
- Squeeze handle drains from the bottom, with a top spout for leftover fat
- Silicone valve and external drain make cleanup easy
Cons- Costs more than the pour-spout OXO and the Vondior
- ATK says the valve takes a firm squeeze to open
- The listing gives no heat limit for hot drippings
- 2. Best Pour-Spout
OXO Good Grips Fat Separator
BeastScore 90 / 100Typically $15–$25 on Amazon (checked November 17, 2026)This is the classic pour-spout design, and it costs less than the bottom-release OXO. You drop the stopper into the spout, pour the drippings through the fine strainer, wait, then pull the stopper and pour. ATK says the stopper builds pressure that keeps fat out of the spout, which works well on large volumes, and Reviewed rated OXO’s pour-spout 4-cup its best value. Take it over the Good Gravy if you want to save a few dollars. Skip it if you don’t like tilting a full pitcher of hot liquid: the plug is easy to lose and ATK found some peppercorns got through the strainer.
Pros- Costs less than the bottom-release OXO
- The stopper keeps fat out of the spout, which ATK says works well on big volumes
- Raised shield, non-slip handle and built-in stopper storage
Cons- Pouring means tilting a full pitcher of hot liquid
- The stopper is easy to lose, and ATK saw some peppercorns slip through
- The listing gives no heat limit
- 3. Best Fat Removal
Cuisipro Fat Separator
BeastScore 88 / 100Typically $30–$40 on Amazon (checked November 17, 2026)Cuisipro is the pick for the cleanest gravy. ATK found it removed the most fat in every test, and Reviewed gave it the best yield of its group, helped by a tall, heavily perforated strainer. The listing says it holds 4 cups, is made of Tritan and comes apart in three pieces, which ATK says made it the easiest to wash by hand. Take it over the OXO if getting the fat out matters most. Skip it if you want clear markings or a quick pour: both tests found the marks hard to read, Reviewed says it drains slowly, and today’s offer is from a third-party seller.
Pros- ATK found it removed the most fat in its tests
- Tall, oversized strainer catches more bits
- Comes apart in three pieces for easy washing
Cons- ATK and Reviewed both found the markings hard to read
- Reviewed says it drains slowly and lets a little fat out the bottom
- The priciest plastic pick, and the listing gives no heat limit
- 4. Best Value Bottom-Release
Vondior Fat Separator
BeastScore 87 / 100Typically $20–$25 on Amazon (checked November 17, 2026)The Vondior uses the same bottom-release idea as the Cuisipro for about $22. Reviewed called it easy to use, said it strains and separates fat well, and put it just behind the Cuisipro. You press the red button on the handle and the juices drip out through a silicone plug. The listing says it is BPA-free, top-shelf dishwasher safe and covered by a 3-year warranty. Take it over the OXO Good Gravy if you want bottom release for a few dollars less. Skip it if you want a test-kitchen winner: ATK’s review does not list it, and Reviewed left it unranked and found the markings hard to read and slightly off.
Pros- Bottom-release design for about $22
- Reviewed says it strains and separates fat well
- Top-shelf dishwasher safe, with a 3-year warranty on the listing
Cons- Reviewed found the markings hard to read and slightly off
- Not a test-kitchen winner: ATK does not list it and Reviewed left it unranked
- The listing says only “heat-resistant”, with no limit
- 5. Best Glass
HIC Kitchen Glass Fat Separator
BeastScore 85 / 100Typically $30–$40 on Amazon (checked November 17, 2026)This is the glass option, with no plastic touching your drippings. The pitcher is borosilicate glass with ¼-cup markings, a pierced stainless strainer and a removable fine-mesh screen, and the listing says it is stovetop and microwave safe to 300°F, so you can reheat the gravy in it. Bustle says reviewers find glass easier to clean when it is greasy. Take it over the plastic models if you want clear glass and finer straining. Skip it if you want a stopper or a dishwasher: the listing says hand wash, Bustle notes there is no stopper and a lower pour shield, and glass can break if dropped.
Pros- Borosilicate glass with a 300°F stovetop and microwave limit on the listing
- Two strainers: pierced steel plus a removable fine-mesh screen
- Clear ¼-cup markings on a 32 oz pitcher
Cons- The listing says hand wash, not the dishwasher
- No stopper and a lower pour shield, so pouring needs care
- Glass can break if dropped, and it sits at the top of the price range
- 6. Best for Hot Stock
Bellemain 4-Cup Fat Separator
BeastScore 83 / 100Typically $20–$25 on Amazon (checked November 17, 2026)Bellemain lists the highest heat limit of the plastic models. The listing says the heavy-duty plastic is heat-resistant to 400°F, so you can pour in stock that is still hot, and the high front is meant to stop the fat sloshing over the rim as you pour. A silicone stopper keeps fat out of the spout and the strainer is built to take pressing on bits. Take it over the OXO if you pour straight from a hot pan. Skip it if separation matters most: Reviewed found liquid spills over the top easily and rated it weaker overall, and you tilt it to pour, so it needs a careful hand.
Pros- Listing says the plastic is heat-resistant to 400°F
- High front and pour shield aimed at fewer spills
- Silicone stopper and a strainer you can press bits through
Cons- Reviewed found liquid spills over the top easily
- Reviewed rated its performance weaker than the OXO and Cuisipro
- 7. Best Budget
Fox Run Gravy Separator
BeastScore 82 / 100Typically $10–$15 on Amazon (checked November 17, 2026)At under $10, this is the cheapest way to get fat out of gravy. It is a clear acrylic cup with a spout and cup and metric markings, and the listing calls it right for gravy at smaller gatherings. You add the liquid, wait for the fat to rise and pour out the juices. Take it over the OXO models if price decides it, or if you cook for a small table and keep the batch small. Skip it for a big bird: it holds only 1.5 cups, the listing mentions no strainer or stopper, and it tells you to let very hot liquid cool before pouring it in.
Pros- Under $10, the lowest price here
- Compact at about 3.5 x 6.5 x 3.5 inches
- Top-rack dishwasher safe on the listing
Cons- Holds only 1.5 cups, so a big batch needs several rounds
- The listing mentions no strainer or stopper
- Listing says to let very hot liquid cool before pouring it in
All 7 compared, in one look
See every pick on one chart, or tap one to put it head to head with OXO Good Grips Good Gravy. Ratings out of 10 are our estimates from published specs and Amazon owner reviews, not hands-on tests. Bigger shape = better.
- Fat removalCuisipro Fat Separator · 9.6/10
- Pour controlOXO Good Grips Good Gravy · 9.4/10
- Easy cleanupOXO Good Grips Good Gravy · 9.2/10
- CapacityTie
- Heat safetyBellemain 4-Cup Fat Separator · 9.4/10
- ValueFox Run Gravy Separator · 9.8/10
Which one should you buy?
Find your situation below. That's your pick.

- You want the separator two test kitchens ranked first
- You want bottom release with a top spout and easy cleanup

- You want the proven pour-spout design for less than the Good Gravy
- You are happy to tilt the pitcher to pour

- You want the least fat in the gravy, per ATK and Reviewed
- You will hand-wash it and can live with faint markings

- You want a 4-cup bottom-release model for about $22
- You do not need a test-kitchen name on the box

- You want glass and no plastic touching your drippings
- You like reheating the gravy in the same pitcher

- You pour in stock or drippings that are still hot
- You want a stopper and a 400°F heat limit on the listing

- You want the lowest price
- You cook for a small table and keep the batch small

OXO Good Grips Good Gravy
The test kitchens’ winner: a 4-cup bottom-release separator with a top spout and an easy-clean valve.
- 4-cup bottom release
- Top spout for leftover fat
- ATK and Reviewed winner
Quick tips before you buy
ATK’s testers prefer a true 4-cup size because smaller ones need several rounds. For a full Thanksgiving table, skip anything smaller unless you cook for a handful of people.
Listings range from Bellemain’s 400°F and HIC’s 300°F to “heat-resistant” with no number. A few minutes off the heat first is a safe habit, and Fox Run’s listing says the same.
Every model here is listed as dishwasher safe except the HIC, but ATK found dishwashers often crack or warp separators and fade the markings. The OXO Good Gravy held up to top-rack testing.
Skip no-name 4-cup models with only a handful of owner reports, anything under 4 cups for a full turkey, and the Cuisipro if you need easy-to-read markings. ATK did not recommend a Küchenprofi glass pitcher that held just over 3 cups.
Quick answers
Bottom release vs pour spout gravy separator: which is better?+
Neither wins outright, but the test kitchens lean bottom release. ATK says its testers preferred bottom-draining models because the fat stays on top and you can stop before it reaches the outlet. With a pour spout, fat can slip into the spout, which gets harder to avoid as the liquid runs low, and a stopper like the OXO’s or Bellemain’s fixes most of that. Bustle adds that bottom-release models are generally easier to clean, but you have to watch the level as you drain. Buy the OXO Good Gravy for the safest bet, or the OXO pour-spout to save a few dollars.
What size gravy separator do I need for a 20 lb turkey?+
A true 4-cup separator. ATK’s testers say that size handles both large and small batches, while smaller models need several rounds. The OXO, Cuisipro, Vondior, HIC and Bellemain here all hold 4 cups, and if you end up with more liquid than that once you add stock, run it through in two rounds. We found no well-reviewed 6 to 8 cup separator on Amazon, so 4 cups is the practical top size. The 1.5-cup Fox Run suits a small gathering only.
Can you put hot drippings in a plastic gravy separator?+
Check the listing’s heat limit first, because they differ. Bellemain says its plastic is heat-resistant to 400°F, and the HIC glass pitcher is stovetop and microwave safe to 300°F. OXO, Cuisipro and Vondior say heat-resistant but give no number, and Bustle notes limits across popular models run from about 226°F to 400°F. Fox Run’s listing says to let very hot liquid cool and avoid boiling-hot liquid straight from the pan. Waiting a few minutes off the heat is the safe habit with any of them.
Glass or plastic gravy separator: which should you buy?+
Plastic is the safer pick for most people: it is light, it will not shatter and most models are listed as dishwasher safe. Glass, like the HIC borosilicate pitcher, keeps plastic away from hot drippings, Bustle says reviewers find it easier to clean when greasy, and the listing allows the stovetop and microwave up to 300°F. The trade-offs are weight, breakage, a hand-wash instruction and, on the HIC, no stopper and a lower pour shield. Glass is not automatically better either: ATK did not recommend a Küchenprofi glass pitcher it tested.
What is the best gravy separator according to America’s Test Kitchen?+
ATK’s equipment review names the OXO Good Grips Good Gravy 4-cup as its winner. It also recommends the Cuisipro 4-cup, which removed the most fat in its tests, and a Trudeau pitcher. Reviewed picked the same OXO as best overall and put OXO’s pour-spout 4-cup second for value, and Serious Eats called the Good Gravy the most accurate, comfortable and well-designed separator it tried. The Trudeau did not appear in our Amazon searches, so it is not a pick here.
Is a gravy separator jug worth buying?+
Yes if you make gravy from pan drippings, even once a year. ATK says a separator defats stock and pan juices almost at once, where chilling them lets the fat harden over hours, and one reviewer in Bustle’s roundup found 3 to 5 minutes of settling enough. The Fox Run is under $10 and the OXO Good Gravy is about $25 to $35, a small cost next to the turkey. Skip it if your gravy comes from a packet or a jar.
Are gravy separators dishwasher safe?+
Most are listed that way: OXO, Cuisipro, Vondior and Bellemain, with Fox Run on the top rack, but the HIC glass listing says hand wash. ATK says every separator it tried can technically go in the dishwasher, yet dishwashers often crack or warp them and fade the markings, so it advises washing by hand. The OXO Good Gravy stayed leakproof through repeated top-rack cycles in its tests. If you use a dishwasher, stay on the top rack.
Keep comparing
Best Roaster Ovens 7 Picks for Every Turkey and BudgetA second oven for the big bird. The best roaster ovens compared.
Best Roasting Pans 7 picks and the turkey each one fitsFits the bird, fits your oven. The best roasting pans compared.
Best Meat Thermometers: Top 5 on AmazonPerfect turkey, steak and brisket. No more guessing.
Best Electric Carving Knives 6 for turkey and breadNeat turkey slices without the sawing. Six electric knives compared, corded and cordless.