BeastCompare

Xiaomi 17 Max 5G vs Xiaomi Redmi Note 17 5G (China): Which One Should You Buy?

These two are too close to call on BeastScore — the right choice depends on what matters to you.

Head-to-head
Comparing 2 devicesSwipe ⇄
Xiaomi

Xiaomi 17 Max 5G

Xiaomi 17 Max 5G
89/ 100
Launch pricePrice on request
Xiaomi

Xiaomi Redmi Note 17 5G (China)

Xiaomi Redmi Note 17 5G (China)
89/ 100
Launch pricePrice on request
Head-to-head

Too close to call: 0 of 5 categories each

Here's exactly where each phone is stronger.

Xiaomi 17 Max 5G
Xiaomi 17 Max 5G
0 wins
Xiaomi Redmi Note 17 5G (China)
Xiaomi Redmi Note 17 5G (China)
0 wins
At a glance

Bigger shape = better phone.

SpeedCameraBatteryDisplayValue
Xiaomi 17 Max 5GXiaomi Redmi Note 17 5G (China)
Category winners

Scores out of 100. How we score

  • SpeedTie
    95
    95
  • CameraTie
    80
    80
  • VideoNot enough data
  • SelfieNot enough data
  • BatteryTie
    95
    95
  • DisplayTie
    89
    89
  • ConnectivityNot enough data
  • SecurityNot enough data
  • ValueTie
    85
    85
Key differences
  • Xiaomi Redmi Note 17 5G (China) has the bigger screen6.99" vs 6.9"
  • Xiaomi 17 Max 5G has more RAM16 GB vs 8 GB
  • Xiaomi 17 Max 5G has the faster chipSnapdragon 8 Elite Gen 5 vs Snapdragon 4 Gen 4
See all specs ↓

Why buy each phone

Swipe ⇄
Reasons to buy Xiaomi 17 Max 5G
  • ✓6.9" display at 120 Hz
Reasons to buy Xiaomi Redmi Note 17 5G (China)
  • ✓6.99" display at 120 Hz

Full specifications

Swipe ⇄
SpecificationXiaomi 17 Max 5GXiaomi Redmi Note 17 5G (China)
1. Display & Screen
Screen typeAMOLEDAMOLED
Screen Size6.9"6.99"
Resolution & DensityFHD+ / LTPO AMOLED FHD+ / LTPO AMOLED
Refresh Rate120 Hz120 Hz
BrightnessN/AN/A
Screen ProtectionNot listedNot listed
2. Platform & Performance
Chipset / ProcessorSnapdragon 8 Elite Gen 5 Snapdragon 4 Gen 4
CPU CoresNot listedNot listed
GPU GraphicsNot listedNot listed
Operating SystemAndroid Android
3. Memory & Storage
RAM Memory16 GB LPDDR8 GB LPDDR
Internal Storage512 GB256 GB
Storage SpeedNot listedNot listed
Card SlotNoNo
4. Main Camera Optics
Primary Cameraundefined MP, Triple Camera Systemundefined MP, Triple Camera System
Telephoto ZoomNone (digital zoom only)None (digital zoom only)
Ultrawide CameraN/AN/A
LiDAR / DepthNoneNone
5. Video
Main Camera Video
Not listed
Not listed
Front Video
Not listed
Not listed
6. Selfie Camera
Selfie Lensundefined MPundefined MP
7. Body & Dimensions
DimensionsN/AN/A
WeightN/AN/A
Build MaterialsNot listedNot listed
SIM TypeNot listedNot listed
Water ResistanceNot listedNot listed
8. Battery & Charging
Battery Capacity8,000 mAh8,000 mAh
Wired Fast ChargingFast chargingFast charging
Wireless ChargingNot listedNot listed
Reverse ChargingNot listedNot listed
9. Sound & Audio
LoudspeakerNot listedNot listed
3.5mm Headphone JackNoNo
10. Connectivity
Wi-Fi StandardNot listedNot listed
BluetoothNot listedNot listed
USB Port & SpeedNot listedNot listed
NFCYesYes
11. Sensors & Security
SensorsNot listedNot listed
Satellite FeaturesNot listedNot listed
12. Colors & Overview
ColorsNot listedNot listed
Launch PricePrice on requestPrice on request
Our verdict

Xiaomi 17 Max 5G and Xiaomi Redmi Note 17 5G (China) are evenly matched

It's a close call. Pick the Xiaomi 17 Max 5G for its more RAM (16 GB vs 8 GB) and faster chip (Snapdragon 8 Elite Gen 5 vs Snapdragon 4 Gen 4), or the Xiaomi Redmi Note 17 5G (China) for its bigger screen (6.99" vs 6.9").

Buy Xiaomi 17 Max 5G if you want

More RAM: 16 GB vs 8 GB

Buy Xiaomi Redmi Note 17 5G (China) if you want

Reliable all-round performance.

Common questions

Which is better: Xiaomi 17 Max 5G or Xiaomi Redmi Note 17 5G (China)?

It's a close call. Pick the Xiaomi 17 Max 5G for its more RAM (16 GB vs 8 GB) and faster chip (Snapdragon 8 Elite Gen 5 vs Snapdragon 4 Gen 4), or the Xiaomi Redmi Note 17 5G (China) for its bigger screen (6.99" vs 6.9"). BeastScore: Xiaomi 17 Max 5G 89.3/100, Xiaomi Redmi Note 17 5G (China) 89.3/100.

What are the main battery and display differences between Xiaomi 17 Max 5G and Xiaomi Redmi Note 17 5G (China)?

Xiaomi 17 Max 5G has a 6.9-inch display and 8000 mAh battery. Xiaomi Redmi Note 17 5G (China) has a 6.99-inch display and 8000 mAh battery.

How do Xiaomi 17 Max 5G and Xiaomi Redmi Note 17 5G (China) compare for speed?

Xiaomi 17 Max 5G scores 95/100 for performance; Xiaomi Redmi Note 17 5G (China) scores 95/100.

Similar Smartphones

Samsung Galaxy F70 Pro 5G
Samsung

Samsung Galaxy F70 Pro 5G

Apple iPhone 18 Pro
Apple

Apple iPhone 18 Pro

Google Pixel 11 Pro 5G
Google

Google Pixel 11 Pro 5G

OnePlus 15T 5G
Oneplus

OnePlus 15T 5G

Xiaomi 17 Ultra 5G
Xiaomi

Xiaomi 17 Ultra 5G

vivo iQOO 15 Ultra 5G
Vivo

vivo iQOO 15 Ultra 5G

OPPO Find X10
Oppo

OPPO Find X10

Motorola Edge 70 Fusion 5G
Motorola

Motorola Edge 70 Fusion 5G

More Smartphones comparisons

vs

Xiaomi 17 Ultra 5G (China) vs Xiaomi 17 Max 5G

Compare →
vs

Xiaomi 17 vs Xiaomi 17 Max 5G

Compare →
vs

Xiaomi 17T 5G vs Xiaomi 17 Max 5G

Compare →
vs

Xiaomi 17 Max 5G vs Xiaomi 17T Pro 5G

Compare →
vs

Xiaomi 17 Max 5G vs Xiaomi 17 Pro

Compare →
vs

Xiaomi 17 Max 5G vs Xiaomi 17 Pro Max

Compare →
vs

Xiaomi Redmi Note 14 vs Xiaomi Redmi Note 17 5G (China)

Compare →
vs

Xiaomi Redmi Note 15 5G (China) vs Xiaomi Redmi Note 17 5G (China)

Compare →

Gear for the Xiaomi 17 Max 5G

All Amazon Finds →
Amazon FindsBest power banksFast charging for a full day out.See the picks Amazon FindsBest USB-C chargersSmall GaN bricks that charge fast.See the picks Amazon FindsBest wireless earbudsTop 5 on Amazon, compared.See the picks Amazon FindsBest Bluetooth trackersAirTag vs SmartTag2 vs Tile.See the picks

Related articles

All articles →
Samsung Galaxy Z Flip6 vs. Motorola Razr+ (2024) vs. Xiaomi Mix Flip: The Definitive Flagship Clamshell Foldable Architecture, Outer Screen Workflows, Armor Aluminum & Titanium Hinges, Silicon-Carbon Batteries, and Dual 50MP Camera Showdown (2026)Definitive Foldable Guide 2026
14 min read

Samsung Galaxy Z Flip6 vs. Motorola Razr+ (2024) vs. Xiaomi Mix Flip: The Definitive Flagship Clamshell Foldable Architecture, Outer Screen Workflows, Armor Aluminum & Titanium Hinges, Silicon-Carbon Batteries, and Dual 50MP Camera Showdown (2026)

A rigorous 2026 engineering and benchmark comparison of the top three clamshell foldables: evaluating Qualcomm Snapdragon 8 Gen 3 for Galaxy vs. 8s Gen 3, teardrop dual-rail hinge mechanics, 1.5K quad-curved vs. 165Hz cover displays, 4,780mAh silicon-carbon battery chemistry, and Leica vs. ProVisual computational photography.

Read →
Xiaomi starts beta test recruitment for HyperOS 4Update
4 min read

Xiaomi starts beta test recruitment for HyperOS 4

Xiaomi has started recruiting beta testers for HyperOS 4 across eligible flagship devices, focusing on smoother animations, lower background RAM usage, and improved AI features.

Read →
Yep, He Is a Toad: Why Millions Are Obsessed With The Note Toad Desk OrganizerViral Find
3 min read

Yep, He Is a Toad: Why Millions Are Obsessed With The Note Toad Desk Organizer

Tired of losing sticky notes under messy keyboards? Discover why this viral amphibian desk organizer is taking over home offices and college dorms.

Read →