BeastCompare

OnePlus One vs Pixel 2 XL: Which One Should You Buy?

Pixel 2 XL edges ahead with a BeastScore of 64.8/100 — but the right choice depends on what matters to you.

Head-to-head
Comparing 2 devicesSwipe ⇄
Oneplus · 2014

OnePlus One

OnePlus One
65/ 100
Launch price$299
Google · 2017

Pixel 2 XL

Pixel 2 XL
65/ 100
Launch price$849
Head-to-head

Pixel 2 XL wins 3 of 7 categories

Here's exactly where each phone is stronger.

OnePlus One
OnePlus One
1 win
Pixel 2 XL
Pixel 2 XL
3 wins
At a glance

Bigger shape = better phone.

SpeedCameraSelfieBatteryDisplayConnectivityValue
OnePlus OnePixel 2 XL
Category winners

Scores out of 100. How we score

  • SpeedPixel 2 XL
    60
    64
  • CameraPixel 2 XL
    68
    72
  • VideoNot enough data
  • SelfieTie
    40
    40
  • BatteryTie
    58
    58
  • DisplayTie
    62
    62
  • ConnectivityPixel 2 XL
    45
    65
  • SecurityNot enough data
  • ValueOnePlus One
    90
    68
Key differences
  • Pixel 2 XL has the bigger battery3,520 mAh vs 3,100 mAh
  • Pixel 2 XL charges faster18W vs 10W
  • OnePlus One has a sharper main camera13 MP vs 12.2 MP
  • Pixel 2 XL has the bigger screen6" vs 5.5"
  • OnePlus One is lighter162 g vs 175 g
  • OnePlus One launched cheaper$299 vs $849
  • Pixel 2 XL has a sharper selfie camera8 MP vs 5 MP
  • Pixel 2 XL has newer Bluetooth5 vs 4.1
  • Pixel 2 XL has more RAM4 GB vs 3 GB
See all specs ↓

Why buy each phone

Swipe ⇄
Reasons to buy OnePlus One
  • ✓13 g lighter (162 g vs 175 g), easier to hold
  • ✓$550 cheaper at launch ($299 vs $849)
  • ✓13 MP main camera
Reasons to buy Pixel 2 XL
  • ✓Bigger 3,520 mAh battery (+420 mAh)
  • ✓12.2 MP main camera
  • ✓6" display at 60 Hz

Full specifications

Swipe ⇄
SpecificationOnePlus OnePixel 2 XL
1. Display & Screen
Screen typeLTPS LCDP-OLED
Screen Size5.5"6"
Resolution & Density1920x1080 (401 ppi)2880x1440 (538 ppi)
Refresh Rate60 Hz60 Hz
Brightness480 nits peak400 nits peak
Screen ProtectionNot listedNot listed
2. Platform & Performance🏆 Pixel 2 XL Wins Performance
Chipset / ProcessorNot listed Not listed
CPU CoresNot listedNot listed
GPU GraphicsNot listedNot listed
Operating SystemAndroid 4.4Android 8.0
3. Memory & Storage
RAM Memory3 GB LPDDR4 GB LPDDR
Internal Storage16GB / 64GB64GB / 128GB
Storage SpeedNot listedNot listed
Card SlotNoNo
4. Main Camera Optics🏆 Pixel 2 XL Wins Camera
Primary Camera13 MP, f/2, Sony IMX21412.2 MP, f/1.8, OIS
Telephoto ZoomNone (digital zoom only)None (digital zoom only)
Ultrawide CameraN/AN/A
LiDAR / DepthNoneNone
5. Video
Main Camera Video
Not listed
Not listed
Front Video
Not listed
Not listed
6. Selfie Camera
Selfie Lens5 MP, f/28 MP, f/2.4
7. Body & Dimensions🏆 OnePlus One Lightest Chassis
Dimensions152.9 x 75.9 x 8.9 mm157.9 x 76.7 x 7.9 mm
Weight162 g175 g
Build MaterialsNot listedNot listed
SIM TypeNot listedNot listed
Water ResistanceNot listedIP67
8. Battery & Charging
Battery Capacity3,100 mAh3,520 mAh
Wired Fast Charging10W wired fast charging18W wired fast charging
Wireless ChargingNot listedNot listed
Reverse ChargingNot listedNot listed
9. Sound & Audio
LoudspeakerNot listedNot listed
3.5mm Headphone JackNoNo
10. Connectivity
Wi-Fi StandardWi-Fi 5Wi-Fi 5
Bluetooth4.15.0
USB Port & SpeedMicro-USB 2.0USB-C 3.1
NFCYes (contactless payment)Yes (contactless payment)
11. Sensors & Security
SensorsNot listedNot listed
Satellite FeaturesNot listedNot listed
12. Colors & Overview
ColorsNot listedNot listed
Launch Price$299$849
Our verdict

Pixel 2 XL wins — BeastScore 64.8/100

The Pixel 2 XL is the better pick for most people thanks to its bigger battery (3,520 mAh vs 3,100 mAh) and faster charging (18W vs 10W). The OnePlus One is worth a look if you prefer its sharper main camera (13 MP vs 12.2 MP).

Buy OnePlus One if you want

Lighter: 162 g vs 175 g (13 g less) · Lower launch price: $299 vs $849

Buy Pixel 2 XL if you want

Larger battery: 3,520 mAh vs 3,100 mAh · Larger display: 6" vs 5.5"

Common questions

Which is better: OnePlus One or Pixel 2 XL?

The Pixel 2 XL is the better pick for most people thanks to its bigger battery (3,520 mAh vs 3,100 mAh) and faster charging (18W vs 10W). The OnePlus One is worth a look if you prefer its sharper main camera (13 MP vs 12.2 MP). BeastScore: OnePlus One 65.0/100, Pixel 2 XL 64.8/100.

What are the main battery and display differences between OnePlus One and Pixel 2 XL?

OnePlus One has a 5.5-inch display and 3100 mAh battery. Pixel 2 XL has a 6-inch display and 3520 mAh battery.

How do OnePlus One and Pixel 2 XL compare for speed?

OnePlus One scores 60/100 for performance; Pixel 2 XL scores 64/100.

Similar Smartphones

Galaxy S9
Samsung

Galaxy S9

iPhone 13
Apple

iPhone 13

Pixel 3
Google

Pixel 3

OnePlus Nord N300 5G TD-LTE US 64GB CPH2389 (BBK 2339)
Oneplus

OnePlus Nord N300 5G TD-LTE US 64GB CPH2389 (BBK 2339)

Xiaomi Redmi A3x 4G Standard Edition Global Dual SIM TD-LTE 64GB 24048RN6CG (Xiaomi Klein)
Xiaomi

Xiaomi Redmi A3x 4G Standard Edition Global Dual SIM TD-LTE 64GB 24048RN6CG (Xiaomi Klein)

BBK Vivo Y01 2022 Standard Edition Dual SIM TD-LTE V3 NP BD KH VN 32GB
Vivo

BBK Vivo Y01 2022 Standard Edition Dual SIM TD-LTE V3 NP BD KH VN 32GB

A3s Dual SIM TD-LTE VN Version 2 16GB CPH1803 / A2 Pro
Oppo

A3s Dual SIM TD-LTE VN Version 2 16GB CPH1803 / A2 Pro

Motorola Razr (2019)
Motorola

Motorola Razr (2019)

More Smartphones comparisons

vs

OnePlus One vs Galaxy S9

Compare →
vs

Pixel 2 XL vs Galaxy S9

Compare →
vs

OnePlus One vs iPhone 13

Compare →
vs

Pixel 2 XL vs iPhone 13

Compare →
vs

OnePlus One vs Pixel 3

Compare →
vs

Pixel 2 XL vs Pixel 3

Compare →
vs

OnePlus One vs OnePlus Nord N300 5G TD-LTE US 64GB CPH2389 (BBK 2339)

Compare →
vs

Pixel 2 XL vs OnePlus Nord N300 5G TD-LTE US 64GB CPH2389 (BBK 2339)

Compare →

Gear for the Pixel 2 XL

All Amazon Finds →
Amazon FindsApple Watch vs Galaxy Watch vs Pixel WatchThe right watch for your phone.See the picks Amazon FindsBest wireless earbudsTop 5 on Amazon, compared.See the picks Amazon FindsBest power banksFast charging for a full day out.See the picks Amazon FindsBest USB-C chargersSmall GaN bricks that charge fast.See the picks

Related articles

All articles →
Samsung Galaxy Z Fold6 vs. Google Pixel 9 Pro Fold vs. Honor Magic V3 vs. OnePlus Open: The Definitive Flagship Foldable Architecture, Hinge Engineering, Crease-Free Displays, and Camera Benchmark Showdown (2026)Flagship Showdown
14 min read

Samsung Galaxy Z Fold6 vs. Google Pixel 9 Pro Fold vs. Honor Magic V3 vs. OnePlus Open: The Definitive Flagship Foldable Architecture, Hinge Engineering, Crease-Free Displays, and Camera Benchmark Showdown (2026)

An exhaustive microarchitectural breakdown, hinge mechanism durability, crease analysis, dual-screen multitasking benchmarks, and periscope camera shootout across the 4 premier book-style foldables of 2026.

Read →
Pixel 10a Now $599 vs Galaxy A57 & iPhone 17e: Still Worth It?Tech News
6 min read

Pixel 10a Now $599 vs Galaxy A57 & iPhone 17e: Still Worth It?

Google quietly raised the Pixel 10a from $499 to $599 in early October, and Samsung pushed the Galaxy A57 up to $599.99 the same week. That puts three "budget" phones at the same $599 starting price as the iPhone 17e. Here is what changed, how the three compare, and which one makes sense now.

Read →
Apple iPhone 16 Pro vs. Google Pixel 9 Pro vs. Samsung Galaxy S24: The Definitive Flagship Compact Smartphone Architecture, 6.3-inch 120Hz LTPO Super Actua & ProMotion Displays, Apple A18 Pro vs. Google Tensor G4 vs. Snapdragon 8 Gen 3 Silicon, 5x Periscope Telephoto Optics, 4K120 ProRes Log, On-Device Gemini Nano & Apple Intelligence, and Real-World Battery Showdown (2026)2026 COMPACT FLAGSHIP BENCHMARKS
15 min read

Apple iPhone 16 Pro vs. Google Pixel 9 Pro vs. Samsung Galaxy S24: The Definitive Flagship Compact Smartphone Architecture, 6.3-inch 120Hz LTPO Super Actua & ProMotion Displays, Apple A18 Pro vs. Google Tensor G4 vs. Snapdragon 8 Gen 3 Silicon, 5x Periscope Telephoto Optics, 4K120 ProRes Log, On-Device Gemini Nano & Apple Intelligence, and Real-World Battery Showdown (2026)

A comprehensive 2,500+ word engineering analysis, thermal dissipation benchmark, camera sensor breakdown, and battery endurance comparison of the premier 6.2-to-6.3-inch pro smartphones.

Read →