Galaxy S III vs Pixel XL: Which One Should You Buy?
Pixel XL edges ahead with a BeastScore of 63.8/100 — but the right choice depends on what matters to you.
Galaxy S III
Pixel XL
Pixel XL wins 3 of 7 categories
Here's exactly where each phone is stronger.
Bigger shape = better phone.
Scores out of 100. How we score
- SpeedPixel XL6064
- CameraPixel XL6068
- VideoNot enough data
- SelfieTie4040
- BatteryTie5858
- DisplayTie6262
- ConnectivityPixel XL5272
- SecurityNot enough data
- ValueGalaxy S III8068
- Pixel XL has the bigger battery3,450 mAh vs 2,100 mAh
- Pixel XL charges faster18W vs 5W
- Pixel XL has a sharper main camera12.3 MP vs 8 MP
- Pixel XL has the bigger screen5.5" vs 4.8"
- Galaxy S III is lighter133 g vs 168 g
- Galaxy S III launched cheaper$599 vs $769
- Pixel XL has a sharper selfie camera8 MP vs 1.9 MP
- Pixel XL has newer Bluetooth4.2 vs 4
- Pixel XL has more RAM4 GB vs 1 GB
Why buy each phone
Swipe ⇄Pixel XL wins — BeastScore 63.8/100
The Pixel XL is the better pick for most people thanks to its bigger battery (3,450 mAh vs 2,100 mAh) and faster charging (18W vs 5W). The Galaxy S III is worth a look if you prefer its lighter body (133 g vs 168 g).
Lighter: 133 g vs 168 g (35 g less) · Lower launch price: $599 vs $769
Larger battery: 3,450 mAh vs 2,100 mAh · Faster wired charging: 18W vs 5W
Common questions
Which is better: Galaxy S III or Pixel XL?
The Pixel XL is the better pick for most people thanks to its bigger battery (3,450 mAh vs 2,100 mAh) and faster charging (18W vs 5W). The Galaxy S III is worth a look if you prefer its lighter body (133 g vs 168 g). BeastScore: Galaxy S III 62.0/100, Pixel XL 63.8/100.
What are the main battery and display differences between Galaxy S III and Pixel XL?
Galaxy S III has a 4.8-inch display and 2100 mAh battery. Pixel XL has a 5.5-inch display and 3450 mAh battery.
How do Galaxy S III and Pixel XL compare for speed?
Galaxy S III scores 60/100 for performance; Pixel XL scores 64/100.
Similar Smartphones
Galaxy S6
iPhone 11 Pro
Pixel
OnePlus One
Xiaomi Redmi A3x 4G Standard Edition Global Dual SIM TD-LTE 64GB 24048RN6CG (Xiaomi Klein)
BBK Vivo Y01 2022 Standard Edition Dual SIM TD-LTE V3 NP BD KH VN 32GB
Oppo A55s 2022 5G TD-LTE JP 64GB A102OP (BBK 2309)
Motorola Razr (2019)
More Smartphones comparisons
Gear for the Pixel XL
All Amazon Finds →Related articles
All articles →
Flagship ShowdownSamsung Galaxy Z Fold6 vs. Google Pixel 9 Pro Fold vs. Honor Magic V3 vs. OnePlus Open: The Definitive Flagship Foldable Architecture, Hinge Engineering, Crease-Free Displays, and Camera Benchmark Showdown (2026)
An exhaustive microarchitectural breakdown, hinge mechanism durability, crease analysis, dual-screen multitasking benchmarks, and periscope camera shootout across the 4 premier book-style foldables of 2026.
Read →
Flagship Monitor ShootoutSamsung Odyssey Neo G9 57" vs. Odyssey OLED G9 49" vs. ASUS ROG Swift PG49WCD vs. LG UltraGear 45GS96QB: The Definitive Flagship Super Ultrawide & Curved Gaming Monitor Architecture, Dual 4K 7680x2160 vs. Dual QHD QD-OLED, DisplayPort 2.1 Bandwidth (UHBR 13.5/20), 240Hz Refresh Rates, 2,392 Mini-LED Local Dimming Zones vs. Infinite Contrast OLED, KVM Multitasking, and GPU Driveability Shootout (2026)
A comprehensive architectural shootout of the world's most advanced curved super ultrawide monitors. We compare Samsung's 57-inch Dual 4K Quantum Mini-LED titan against 49-inch Gen 2 QD-OLEDs and LG's 45-inch 800R curved WOLED across DisplayPort 2.1 bandwidth tunneling, 240Hz motion clarity, text rendering subpixel matrices, multi-window KVM workflows, and GPU horsepower requirements.
Read →
Tech NewsPixel 10a Now $599 vs Galaxy A57 & iPhone 17e: Still Worth It?
Google quietly raised the Pixel 10a from $499 to $599 in early October, and Samsung pushed the Galaxy A57 up to $599.99 the same week. That puts three "budget" phones at the same $599 starting price as the iPhone 17e. Here is what changed, how the three compare, and which one makes sense now.
Read →