Galaxy S8 vs Pixel 2 XL: Which One Should You Buy?
Galaxy S8 edges ahead with a BeastScore of 64.8/100 — but the right choice depends on what matters to you.
Galaxy S8
Pixel 2 XL
Galaxy S8 wins 1 of 8 categories
Here's exactly where each phone is stronger.
Bigger shape = better phone.
Scores out of 100. How we score
- SpeedTie6464
- CameraTie7272
- VideoNot enough data
- SelfieTie4040
- BatteryTie5858
- DisplayTie6262
- ConnectivityTie6565
- SecurityGalaxy S810086
- ValueTie6868
- Pixel 2 XL has the bigger battery3,520 mAh vs 3,000 mAh
- Pixel 2 XL charges faster18W vs 15W
- Pixel 2 XL has a sharper main camera12.2 MP vs 12 MP
- Pixel 2 XL has the bigger screen6" vs 5.8"
- Galaxy S8 is lighter155 g vs 175 g
- Galaxy S8 launched cheaper$724 vs $849
- Galaxy S8 is better protected from water and dustIP68 vs IP67
Why buy each phone
Swipe ⇄Galaxy S8 wins — BeastScore 64.8/100
The Galaxy S8 is the better pick for most people thanks to its lighter body (155 g vs 175 g) and lower launch price ($724 vs $849). The Pixel 2 XL is worth a look if you prefer its bigger battery (3,520 mAh vs 3,000 mAh).
Lighter: 155 g vs 175 g (20 g less) · Lower launch price: $724 vs $849
Larger battery: 3,520 mAh vs 3,000 mAh
Common questions
Which is better: Galaxy S8 or Pixel 2 XL?
The Galaxy S8 is the better pick for most people thanks to its lighter body (155 g vs 175 g) and lower launch price ($724 vs $849). The Pixel 2 XL is worth a look if you prefer its bigger battery (3,520 mAh vs 3,000 mAh). BeastScore: Galaxy S8 64.8/100, Pixel 2 XL 64.8/100.
What are the main battery and display differences between Galaxy S8 and Pixel 2 XL?
Galaxy S8 has a 5.8-inch display and 3000 mAh battery. Pixel 2 XL has a 6-inch display and 3520 mAh battery.
How do Galaxy S8 and Pixel 2 XL compare for speed?
Galaxy S8 scores 64/100 for performance; Pixel 2 XL scores 64/100.
Similar Smartphones
Galaxy S9
iPhone 13
Pixel 3
OnePlus One
Xiaomi Redmi A3x 4G Standard Edition Global Dual SIM TD-LTE 64GB 24048RN6CG (Xiaomi Klein)
BBK Vivo Y01 2022 Standard Edition Dual SIM TD-LTE V3 NP BD KH VN 32GB
A3s Dual SIM TD-LTE VN Version 2 16GB CPH1803 / A2 Pro
Motorola Razr (2019)
Gear for the Galaxy S8
All Amazon Finds →Related articles
All articles →
Flagship ShowdownSamsung Galaxy Z Fold6 vs. Google Pixel 9 Pro Fold vs. Honor Magic V3 vs. OnePlus Open: The Definitive Flagship Foldable Architecture, Hinge Engineering, Crease-Free Displays, and Camera Benchmark Showdown (2026)
An exhaustive microarchitectural breakdown, hinge mechanism durability, crease analysis, dual-screen multitasking benchmarks, and periscope camera shootout across the 4 premier book-style foldables of 2026.
Read →
Flagship Monitor ShootoutSamsung Odyssey Neo G9 57" vs. Odyssey OLED G9 49" vs. ASUS ROG Swift PG49WCD vs. LG UltraGear 45GS96QB: The Definitive Flagship Super Ultrawide & Curved Gaming Monitor Architecture, Dual 4K 7680x2160 vs. Dual QHD QD-OLED, DisplayPort 2.1 Bandwidth (UHBR 13.5/20), 240Hz Refresh Rates, 2,392 Mini-LED Local Dimming Zones vs. Infinite Contrast OLED, KVM Multitasking, and GPU Driveability Shootout (2026)
A comprehensive architectural shootout of the world's most advanced curved super ultrawide monitors. We compare Samsung's 57-inch Dual 4K Quantum Mini-LED titan against 49-inch Gen 2 QD-OLEDs and LG's 45-inch 800R curved WOLED across DisplayPort 2.1 bandwidth tunneling, 240Hz motion clarity, text rendering subpixel matrices, multi-window KVM workflows, and GPU horsepower requirements.
Read →
Tech NewsPixel 10a Now $599 vs Galaxy A57 & iPhone 17e: Still Worth It?
Google quietly raised the Pixel 10a from $499 to $599 in early October, and Samsung pushed the Galaxy A57 up to $599.99 the same week. That puts three "budget" phones at the same $599 starting price as the iPhone 17e. Here is what changed, how the three compare, and which one makes sense now.
Read →